What matters, in the order you do it. Written by a seller who lists singles every week; SpeedLister automates most of steps 2 through 4.
Front, back, and the card in a penny sleeve inside a toploader. The third photo tells the buyer how it ships and shows you handle cards properly. Shoot straight on, fill the frame, no flash, no carpet. Buyers zoom on corners and edges, so if there's a flaw, photograph it; a surprise on arrival costs you the sale and the feedback.
Order: year, brand, set, player, card number, parallel or insert, then RC for a rookie and the grade if slabbed. Example: 2023 Topps Chrome Elly De La Cruz #170 Refractor RC Reds. Skip "WOW", "L@@K", "hot" and emoji; they take characters from words buyers actually type. Don't put the condition in the title unless it's graded.
Sport, League, Player, Team, Year, Set, Card Number, Parallel/Variety, Features (Rookie, Autograph, Serial Numbered, Insert), Manufacturer, and Graded (Yes/No, with grader and grade if yes). These feed eBay's left-side filters and the price guide match, so a listing with blanks is invisible to a buyer who filters by team or set. Fill all of them even when they seem redundant with the title.
For ungraded cards eBay's condition options are limited; the description is where you earn trust. Cover corners, edges, surface and centering in a sentence or two, and name any print line, dent or wax stain. Never grade from a photo and never promise "gem mint" on a raw card. "Pack fresh, sharp corners, light surface scratch on the back visible in photo 2" sells better than "MINT!!!" because it reads as true.
Check sold listings (not active) for the same card and parallel in the last 90 days. If there are comps, list fixed price at the median with Best Offer on. If the card has real demand (a hot rookie, a numbered parallel, a popular team), a 7-day auction starting at $0.99 or a small floor usually finds the market faster. For cards under $20, a floor around $1.50 keeps you from shipping at a loss.
Most card buyers are in the Eastern and Central time zones and bid in the evening. End between 8 and 10 PM Eastern on Sunday or Monday. A 7-day auction you want to end Monday at 8:30 PM Eastern starts the previous Monday at 5:30 PM Pacific. Avoid ending during a major game or a holiday.
Penny sleeve, toploader, team bag, taped to a piece of cardboard or in a rigid card mailer. Under $20, eBay Standard Envelope ships for well under a dollar with tracking. Over $20, a bubble mailer with Ground Advantage. Set your handling time to 1 business day; it lifts your placement in search. Default package: 1 oz, 7 x 4.35 x 0.09 in for a standard card mailer.
Feedback is what the next buyer checks before bidding with a seller they don't know, and most buyers never leave it unless asked. Once the card has arrived, send one short message: thank them, ask them to message you first if anything is off, and ask for feedback if they're happy. One message, never two.
Listing Pokémon or other TCG singles? The Pokémon guide covers set codes, rarity and language. Deciding between tools? See the comparison.